Freestanding emergency departments are popular, but do they function as intended?
Freestanding emergency departments (EDs)—either satellite branches of hospitals or independently operated facilities—have popped up across the country. Texas has the most, with 338 freestanding EDs as of May 2023, and these facilities handle nearly one quarter of all emergency department visits in the state.
Now, a new study from the Texas A&M University School of Public Health is the first to compare the characteristics of visits to freestanding EDs with visits to traditional hospital-based emergency departments. The study, published in Health Services Research, was conducted by Daniel Marthey, PhD, Benjamin Ukert, PhD, and a student from the Texas A&M School of Medicine.
“Freestanding health care facilities were intended to provide more cost-effective and convenient alternatives to hospital EDs, but this has not turned out to be the case according to the existing research,” Marthey said. “The costs are about the same, as is the volume at hospital EDs.”
Marthey said previous research found that Medicare spending increased after urgent care centers—which don’t have the capabilities of a fully equipped emergency room and are not open around the clock—came on the scene. These centers likely were entry points for hospital services, despite having lower costs.
“While useful, previous studies use payer-specific data and only observe the subset of urgent care centers, leaving important gaps in our understanding of how patients in Texas use all freestanding EDs,” Marthey said.
For this study, the researchers compared patient and visit characteristics at satellite and independent freestanding EDs and hospital EDs in Texas in 2021–2022 using publicly available Texas Emergency Department Public Use Data Files. They used a descriptive analysis with chi-square tests to compare patient and visit characteristics at satellite and independent freestanding EDs and hospital EDs.
They ranked the top 20 diagnoses and procedures by volume, treatment intensity and potentially avoidable ED use. Discharge data from 2021 to 2022 were combined for the analysis, and ED data at critical access hospitals were excluded. The study sample consisted of 21,605,421 ED visits, with 76 percent occurring at hospitals, 12 percent at satellite freestanding EDs and 12 percent at independent freestanding EDs.
“In short, we found that nearly 24 percent of all ED visits occurred at satellite and independent freestanding EDs,” Ukert said. “These patients were younger, healthier and less likely to be identified as non-Hispanic Black or Hispanic. They also were more likely to have private insurance and their visits were more likely to be due to issues that could have been managed in a primary care setting.”
Patients at satellite freestanding EDs more closely tracked the population treated by their hospital counterparts. The health issues of patients visiting satellite and independent freestanding EDs were more likely to be moderate and low intensity and potentially avoidable. Visits at these facilities were more likely to be respiratory related, to lead to more procedures that involved testing for COVID-19 and more likely to be classified as being of moderate and low intensity severity.
“Freestanding emergency departments have become an important source of emergency medical services in Texas,” Ukert said. “This study underscores the need for researchers and policymakers to consider the role of freestanding EDs on inpatient services and other factors affecting the volume of hospital emergency room services.”
The post Freestanding emergency departments are popular, but do they function as intended? appeared first on Vital Record.
Latest Texas A&M Health
- New research sheds light on why college students in Mexico choose to vapeMany smokers begin using tobacco products as young adults, and vaping—consuming tobacco through an e-cigarette or other device that typically uses a battery, heating element and a liquid to produce an inhalable aerosol—is the method of choice for this age group. Users often believe that e-cigarettes are safer than regular cigarettes or can help smokers… The post New research sheds light on why college students in Mexico choose to vape appeared first on Vital Record.
- Novel mobile air monitoring technology yields greater insight into post-disaster pollution levelsA team including researchers from the Texas A&M University School of Public Health and School of Medicine has found that high resolution mass spectrometry could be a valuable tool for identifying and assessing air-borne contaminants produced by natural and man-made disasters. Their findings were published in the Journal of Exposure Science & Environmental Epidemiology. The… The post Novel mobile air monitoring technology yields greater insight into post-disaster pollution levels appeared first on Vital Record.
- Samba Reddy appointed editor of Experimental NeurologySamba Reddy, PhD, RPh, Regents Professor in the Department of Neuroscience and Experimental Therapeutics and director of the Institute of Pharmacology and Neurotherapeutics at Texas A&M University School of Medicine, has been appointed the editor of Experimental Neurology, a prestigious monthly peer-reviewed medical journal. Experimental Neurology, renowned for its focus on neuroscience research on the… The post Samba Reddy appointed editor of Experimental Neurology appeared first on Vital Record.
- National Nurses Week: Nurses Make the DifferenceNational Nurses Week is May 6-12, and the Texas A&M University School of Nursing is putting the spotlight on our exceptional Aggie nurses. In honor of this year’s national theme, we asked some students, faculty and staff how “Nurses Make the Difference.” Sarah Dailey, BSN, RN ’11 Nurse Home Visitor, Nurse-Family Partnership at Texas A&M… The post National Nurses Week: Nurses Make the Difference appeared first on Vital Record.
- A decade later, Obamacare remains a political battlefield in the minds of AmericansThe 2010 Affordable Care Act (ACA) was one of the most significant—and controversial—regulatory overhauls of health care coverage in U.S. history. The ACA affected millions of Americans by increasing access to Medicaid and reducing the costs of health insurance and health care in general. While the ACA continues to shape U.S. health care policy at… The post A decade later, Obamacare remains a political battlefield in the minds of Americans appeared first on Vital Record.
- George Martinez honored with educator award at Central Texas Veterans Healthcare SystemGeorge Martinez, MD, has been honored at the Central Texas Veterans Healthcare System, receiving the distinguished Texas A&M University School of Medicine Department of Medical Education Mid-to Late Career Educator Award. This recognition celebrates Martinez’s exceptional dedication and remarkable contributions to medical education and leadership within the institution. Martinez’s illustrious career spanning over three decades… The post George Martinez honored with educator award at Central Texas Veterans Healthcare System appeared first on Vital Record.